law article review example

admin/ August 22, 2018/ help

The Faculty Lounge

Conversations about law, culture, and academia

Search the Lounge

  • Search the Lounge

Categories

  • AALS
  • ABA
  • Academia
  • Accreditation
  • Administrative Announcements
  • Advertising
  • African American History and Law
  • Airline News and Views
  • ALI
  • Arts and Culture
  • Bar Examinations
  • Beyond Categorization
  • Blogs and Blogging
  • Board Diversity
  • Books
  • Business Organizations
  • Calls for Papers
  • Clerkships
  • Conference News
  • Constitutional History
  • Constitutional Law
  • Criminal Law
  • Culture of Commerce
  • Current Affairs
  • Deans
  • Death Penalty
  • Disability Rights
  • Distance Education
  • Economy and Markets
  • Education
  • Elections and Voting
  • Ethics
  • Eugenics
  • European Financial Crisis
  • Faculty Compensation
  • Fairness and Justice
  • Family Law
  • Fear
  • Fellowships
  • Film
  • Financial Market Regulation
  • Food and Drink
  • Food, Arts & Culture
  • Funny Stuff
  • Games
  • Gender
  • GLBT
  • Harper Lee Symposium
  • Health
  • Intellectual Property
  • International Law
  • Internet
  • Journalism
  • Judiciary
  • Language
  • Law and Economics
  • Law Firms and Practice
  • Law Reviews
  • Law School Deans
  • Law School Hiring
  • Law School News
  • Law School Rankings
  • Legal Education
  • Legal History
  • Literature and Law
  • Memorial Notices
  • Monuments
  • Music
  • News Media
  • Nineteenth Century History
  • Non-Law School Hiring
  • Pedagogy and Assessment
  • Photo Archive
  • Politics
  • Privacy
  • Property
  • Race
  • Rankings
  • Recent Scholarship
  • Religion
  • Religion and Faith
  • Reparations
  • Reproductive Markets
  • Scholarship Strategy
  • Science
  • Sentencing
  • Sexuality
  • Slavery
  • Sociology
  • Sporting Life
  • Sports
  • Starting A Law School
  • Stuff You Can’t Categorize
  • Supreme Court
  • Taboo Trades
  • Teaching
  • Television
  • Terrorism
  • Travel
  • Trusts and Estates
  • University News
  • Web/Tech
  • Weblogs
  • Writing/Clinic Faculty Searches

See More

Reading Room

  • Above The Law
  • Adjunct Law Prof Blog
  • Antitrust & Competition Policy Blog
  • Balkinization
  • Brian Leiter’s Law School Reports
  • Brian Leiter’s Legal Philosophy Blog
  • Brian Leiter’s Nietzsche Blog
  • Business Law Prof Blog
  • Cambridge University Press NA Blog
  • Capital Defense Weekly
  • Chris Uggen’s Weblog
  • CLR FORUM
  • Commercial Law
  • Concurring Opinions
  • Conglomerate
  • Criminal Law and Criminal Justice Books
  • CrimProf Blog
  • Dorf on Law
  • Election Law
  • Empirical Legal Studies
  • Feminist Law Professors
  • First Amendment Law Prof
  • Gender & Sexuality Law Blog
  • Harvard University Press Blog
  • How Appealing
  • Ideoblog
  • Info/Law
  • Institutional Review Blog
  • IntLawGrrls
  • Law Librarian Blog
  • Law School Innovation
  • Law, Economics & Cycling
  • Legal History Blog
  • Legal Scholarship Blog
  • Legal Theory Blog
  • Madisonian
  • Mirror of Justice
  • MoneyLaw
  • Nancy Rapoport’s Blogspot
  • NYU Press Blog
  • Opinio Juris
  • OUP Blog
  • PrawfsBlawg
  • Professor Bainbridge
  • PropertyProf
  • Ratio Juris
  • ReligiousLeftLaw
  • Reproductive Rights Prof
  • scatterplot
  • SCOTUSblog
  • Sentencing Law and Policy
  • Sports Law Blog
  • TaxProf
  • The Becker-Posner Blog
  • The Right Coast
  • The Situationist
  • The Volokh Conspiracy
  • Truth on the Market
  • Turtle Talk
  • University of California Press Blog
  • University of Chicago Press Blog
  • Voir Dire
  • White Collar Crime Prof Blog
  • Word on the Streeterville
  • Workplace Prof
  • WSJ Law Blog
  • Yale Press Log

« Live Blogging from the Archives |
Main
| Possible West/Foundation sale, fewer law students next Fall, and why law education should look to dental education »

January 23, 2012

How to Write a Good Abstract for a Law Review Article

MacClassic
When you write an abstract, you are marketing your own work–you act as your own PR agent.p You’ve already done the work of writing your article, and now you must do the good work of presenting your research Lite-style to articles editors. Aside from your school’s letterhead, it’s the most influential aspect of your paper.p Think of it as intellectual plastic surgery: you augment the exterior to convey to others how you think you should be seen. (See, Jocelyn Wildenstein )

We’ve seen fabulous advice on other blogs about writing a really good abstract ( Dudziak and Volokh ). They are great for achieving the appropriate tone and style that will impress student editors.p Missing from these instructions is a MadLib-style skeleton. Sometimes, it’s nice to sit back and be uncreative in your creativity. (See, "Sh!t [insert very specific demographic here] People Say" meme. If you have no idea what this is, click here .)p First time writers or seasoned scholars all can benefit from a 1040-EZ approach to abstract writing that conveys scholarly import without seeming overtly boastful.

After all, your paper is the most important thing ever written, right?p The other people that wrote on the same thing tried to do it right, but your new idea is so amazing too?p And you have a recommendation for improvement or a different way of seeing things?p Just like my new way of writing abstracts?

Here is is: short and sweet.p Fill in the blanks and Voila!p You are on your way to publication. Follow this abstractoskeleton, and you will have an excellent abstract. Other people may have their own way of doing it, or disagree with my ordering…but then they should write their own abstracts.

Sentence #1:p FIRST PARAGRAPH. State the landscape–what is the current state of things?p One short, actively-verbed sentence.
#2: State the problem–What’s wrong with that landscape you just mentioned? What will happen?p Paint a bleak, end-of-days picture.
#3: Quickly say what you think needs to be done.p This is the most important single sentence in your abstract.p You should be able to describe your entire paper here. You must do it in one sentence.
#4: What have others written about this?p Choose someone big with a well cited book or paper.
#5: What are those other arguments missing?p
#6: SECOND PARAGRAPH: How would you do it differently? Do you have a theoretical lens that would make for an interesting analysis?
#7: Why is this paper important? In one sentence, you should end by stating the intellectual contribution that your paper makes.

Posted by Kevin Maillard at 08:59 AM in Law Reviews | Permalink

|

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Kelly Anders

Speaking as a former journalist, I think writing an effective abstract is akin to creating a good headline for a news article. It needs to give the gist, while still encouraging readers to want to read further. Ideally, an abstract shouldn’t be too long; depending on the topic, a second paragraph may not always be necessary. However, these seven steps provide excellent guidance on what to include. I would add that one should refrain from writing an abstract in the first person (i.e., never use "I").

Posted by:
Kelly Anders |
January 23, 2012 at 10:40 AM

Jacqui Lipton

And to add even more analogies, when sending query letters to magazines for fiction and non-fiction articles, authors need a ‘hook’ and a paragraph explaining what is new and exciting about their article and why they are the person who the magazine should contract with to write the article. It’s a pretty similar exercise, although in a query letter, one does tend to use the first person.

Posted by:
Jacqui Lipton |
January 23, 2012 at 01:18 PM

Steven Lubet

What is wrong with using the first person in an article abstract at the submission stage? Query letters and book proposals always use the first person, as do research agendas. Why would a submission abstract be different (as opposed the ultimate abstract at the beginning of a published piece, which is roughly the equivalent of jacket copy on a book)?

Posted by:
Steven Lubet |
January 23, 2012 at 06:29 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.

Recent Comments

  • Tony Smith on Berkeley Law Seeks New Faculty
  • anon on Berkeley Law Seeks New Faculty
  • Tony Smith on Berkeley Law Seeks New Faculty
  • Steve DIamond on AAUP Opposes Anti-BDS Legislation [UPDATED]
  • anon on Berkeley Law Seeks New Faculty
  • Russell on AAUP Opposes Anti-BDS Legislation [UPDATED]
  • Cranky Pants on Berkeley Law Seeks New Faculty
  • anon on Berkeley Law Seeks New Faculty
  • Steve L. on Plane Wreck at Los Gatos [UPDATED with Pete Seeger clip at the end]
  • James Grimmelmann on Plane Wreck at Los Gatos [UPDATED with Pete Seeger clip at the end]

Bloggers

  • Dan Filler
  • Laura Appleman
  • Alfred L. Brophy
  • Calvin Massey
  • Timothy Zinnecker
  • Jacqueline Lipton
  • Kimberly Krawiec
  • Eric Muller
  • Bridget Crawford
  • Michelle Meyer
  • Jeff Redding
  • Steven Lubet
  • Bernie Burk
  • Anthony Gaughan

Bloggers Emereti

  • Kevin Noble Maillard
  • Kathleen Bergin

Guests, Current and Past

  • Adam Benforado
  • Beth Haas
  • Beth Thornburg
  • Bill Reynolds
  • Brando Starkey
  • Brian Clarke
  • Brian Sawers
  • C. Scott Pryor
  • Cassandra Burke Robertson
  • Daniel Sokol
  • David J.R. Frakt
  • David Orentlicher
  • David S. Cohen
  • David Yellen
  • Derek W. Black
  • Diane Curtis
  • Donald Tibbs
  • Ediberto Roman
  • Ediberto Román
  • Elizabeth M. Glazer
  • Elizabeth R. Dale
  • Eric Chaffee
  • Eric Chiappinelli
  • Franita Tolson
  • Gary Rosin
  • Greg McNeal
  • Gregg D. Polsky
  • Jeff Lipshaw
  • Jessie Hill
  • Jessie Owley
  • John Inazu
  • John Kang
  • Joshua Stein
  • Kathy Stanchi
  • Kelly Anders
  • Marc Roark
  • Mark C. Weidemaier
  • Matt Lister
  • Michael Higdon
  • Michael J. Madison
  • Michael Lewyn
  • Michelle Meyer
  • Miriam Cherry
  • Nancy Rapoport
  • Nareissa Smith
  • Patrick S. O’Donnell
  • Paul McGreal
  • Phil Pucillo
  • Ralph Clifford
  • Ray Campbell
  • Richard Gershon
  • Rita Trivedi
  • Robert Heverly
  • Robert Spitzer
  • Roger Dennis
  • Sarah Lawsky
  • Scott Taylor
  • Sharona Hoffman
  • Sheila B. Scheuerman
  • Steven Lubet
  • Taja-Nia Y. Henderson
  • Tamara Piety
  • Tommy Crocker
  • Tuan Samahon
Subscribe to this blog’s feed

StatCounter

  • StatCounter

    shopify analytics

Blog powered by Typepad

Archives

  • August 12, 2018 – August 18, 2018
  • August 5, 2018 – August 11, 2018
  • July 29, 2018 – August 4, 2018
  • July 22, 2018 – July 28, 2018
  • July 15, 2018 – July 21, 2018
  • July 8, 2018 – July 14, 2018
  • July 1, 2018 – July 7, 2018
  • June 24, 2018 – June 30, 2018
  • June 17, 2018 – June 23, 2018
  • June 10, 2018 – June 16, 2018

More…